EXAMINATION OF THE POSSIBLE MICROSCALE PHYSICAL/CHEMICAL
MECHANISMS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE OBSERVED PERFORMANCE OF THE XCAPER®
SMOKE FILTER
The Xcaper filter is a new type of smoke filtering device
claiming a very high level of efficiency in filtering out
the toxins and particulate products of combustion from common
fires. A professional fire protection device called WHIFFS®,
Wilfire Hazardous Inhalation Firefighters' Filtration System,
holds an Xcaper filter in a protective Nomex® shroud that
is worn over the nose and mouth and allows the wearer to breathe
normally, maintain a clear line of vision, and keep both hands
free.
The Xcaper filter has undergone rigorous laboratory testing
through an independent laboratory and it has also been informally
field tested under a variety of conditions. Since the filter
eliminates a significant percentage of the gas phase products
of combustion, a question arises as to how the observed effectiveness
of the filter in preventing toxic substance build-up in the
body for extended periods of up to 4 hours or more can be explained.
The purpose of this paper is to identify several possible physical
and chemical mechanisms by which the filter's performance may
be explained and is the result of extensive discussions with
individuals highly educated in fire science.
The functional aspects of the filtering process are complex.
They are dependent on details of the filter's construction
as well as on the physical and environmental conditions of
use. Among the most readily identifiable mechanisms are the
following:
As a rather densely packed collection of small plastic beads
in a contained natural gel bath, the filter behaves most fundamentally
as a simple physical absorption device, utilizing a large
enclosed volume for 'storage' of breath-entrained combustion
particulate matter.
The active thickness of the filter offers substantial interference
with the path of smoke particulates drawn in through the normal
breathing process. Given the internal packing structure of
fine beads and relatively small void fraction it is clear,
even without quantification of the effect, that the mean travel
distance (mean path length) of a smoke particle from outer
to inner surface of the filter would be several times the
direct linear thickness of the filter. As interstitial spaces
(between the beads) fill with trapped particulates, mean path
lengths would increase far more, delaying arrival of particulates
at the inner surface.
Over the course of active travel of combustion particulates,
well known "aging" effects alter both their character
and behavior. This widely observed phenomenon, generally termed
coagulation, describes the agglomeration and coalescing behavior
of gaseous, liquid, small solid and aerosol products into
much larger masses whose number and size vary in a complex
manner with both time and ambient temperature. Coagulation
traps large numbers of toxic gas molecules within the clotted
mass, the effect being enhanced by longer residence times
and cooler temperatures.
The physical structure of a smoke particulate may be thought
of as characterized by a large surface area and a variable
surface electric charge resulting from the polar structures
of its constituent molecules. Polar charges of the far smaller
molecules of the remaining free gaseous combustion products
will eventually cause electrochemical adsorption of the gases
onto the surfaces of the particulates. Due to the very large-scale
difference between a gas molecule and even the smallest of
particulates, it is likely that thousands of gas molecules
can adhere to the surface of a single particulate given sufficient
residence time for adsorption to occur.
Most common gases, especially those typically found as combustion
by-products, are soluble in water and other solvents and natural
gels. Free gases not yet trapped by aerosol formation or by
adsorption/coagulation processes are subject to secondary
entrapment through dissociation in a solvent gel.
Still other mechanisms may be of importance, particularly
as they affect the movement of ionic or surface charged species
through the filter. Among these are electrolytic solution
tension effects (i.e., Helmholtz double layer effects), electrophoretic
effects, and potential equilibrium altering gas-solvent reactions.
Such "secondary" mechanisms could be considered
insignificant, but the exceedingly long reaction residence
times characteristic of this type of filter may lead to enhanced
effects which would not normally be expected.
SUMMARY
In view of the major roles played by such processes as adsorption,
aerosol formation and coagulation in typical fire and smoke
aging processes, it is likely that these mechanisms, along
with the added effects of absorption, interference and solvent-induced
dissociation, are also important in accounting for the observed
performance of the Xcaper filter. It is also possible that
other mechanisms related to microscale details of the electrochemical
environment within the filter can be identified as possible
contributors.